It's got a dot and it has hash lines and is a Christmas tree but that's about where the similarity ends. That's like saying the Ford Mustang and Porsche 918 Spyder look alike just because they have wheels, engines and paint jobs. True the MP-8 Extreme was a great reticle for it's time, but I do not see the Gen 3 XR reticle being "just like" it??? Each to their own I suppose, but to me the newer .2 mil hash reticles like the SKMR series, MR4, EBR-7B and now the Gen 3 XR are more "usable" even though the older .5 mil rets worked very well.