Clarification on my end, I was not commenting about "should this be going on" I was trying to determine what the cutoff for determining if a GMO dire wolf is a dire wolf.
The philosophical questions around the creation of the creatures is a really difficult to to answer.
the base of the issue as I see it is , we have been modifying living things for as long as people have been around. Plants and animals alike have been permanently and in some cases strangely changed. Is the laboratory just the scary part? Or if they had bred 20 generations of gey wolf to turn into direwolf like creatures would that be better?
Yup... there were no wild poodles or border collies or Great Danes... all created by mankind. From a base animal... given how long it's been going on... possibly dire wolves were among those animals! 10-12K years ago, we had proto cities and certainly civilizations...
Gregor Mendel only Proved what was going on. But "Artificial Selection" has been going on intentionally and unintentionally for almost as long as we have been the alpha species. Carl Sagan did a great segment on this in the brilliant 1980 Cosmos series...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heikegani
Login to view embedded media
Definitely a good thing to throw into any arguments! What's the difference between gene splicing and someone breeding dozens of generations of dogs to create a Wiener-dog selected to catch rats! Guess one argument is that it takes time and contemplation (and a need?) to breed a wiener dog. But science can do it in weeks or months. Making it 'easy' to do. This was part of what many scientists warned about (and Crichton popularized)... was that the folks "Standing on the shoulders of giants" never went through the struggles, contemplation, effort, work and 'time to reflect' that their predecessors went through. They simply pick up a tool and say "Hey, I can use this to do X or Y." There is no reflection on the 'should' vs. the 'can.'
No easy answers... But the questions should be asked. Because the risks of some of this, long term, is apocalyptic. Or not?
We're still due a supervolcano, a massive bleed-out virus, or a giant meteor. So the cosmos is going to reset itself eventually. Maybe we should just concentrate on having fun, doing good works and trying to leave our little corner of the planet better than we found it.
Or, screw it! Let's shoot shit!
Cheers,
Sirhr