Seems i build a short ar every few years now (braced as i live in the state of chiraq) and upon shooting them im just underwhelmed by them the only bonus to me is that its a nice small package but short of that id rather a 16in rifle setup any day of the week
Anyone else feel the same? Or am i just nuts
Depends on what you run through them if talking 5.56, where NAS will match 16” velocities from a 10.5”-11.5” barrel.
Once you go to some of the High Performance Intermediate Cartridges, there isn’t anything you can do to a 5.56 to make it competitive in performance.
For example, once you see a 12” Grendel impact on steel at 800yds right next to a 24” hot-loaded .223 Rem spitting 77gr faster than you can from an AR, you lose interest in .223 Rem really quick, other than logistics.
16” AR-15s are nothing more than an unintentional by-product of really bad infringement thinking in 1934 and the 1960s.
When Colt first made the SP-1 Carbines, they would have preferred to configure them like the XM177E2, not a silly long-barreled 16” weird-looking carbine.
The after-market in the 1980s followed suit, but with heavy barrels from Bushmaster and Eagle Arms. Colt also had heavy-barreled 16” carbines as well.
Some companies still tried to mimic the XM177E2 look with faux moderators, but still used heavy profile barrels, and really missed the mark.
The best thing that ever happened to 16” barrels was MLGS really, which made the cyclic rate and perceived recoil/sight recovery better than CLGS 16”.
But in the end, 16” barrels should have never been a thing with the AR-15. I have a bunch of them, but never shoot them anymore.