Kicking around the .375 E to replace 50 cal. in the ELR-SR role.

243 blows as well along with 308win since im committing blasphemy might as well go all in
You best not mention the Lord's cartridge here......

1717080756908.gif
 
and 416 Barret or 375 CT or 375 CT Improved over 33XC. I guess the 33XC just isn't relevant;)

There's no free lunch with this stuff. Yes, you can get better ELR performance with a Cheytac or BMG based case, but now you've got a significantly larger rifle. Seriously, no one wants to hump or jump a big frame rifle if they have the option for a smaller frame one. So how do you maximize ELR performance in a smaller / lighter footprint?

As was mentioned before, it sounds like that's the whole point here - maximizing ELR performance to 2500 yards in a normal magnum scale/mass rifle. That tells me you're limited to something between Lapua & Cheytac-ish boltface size, and what barrel length/profile gets you within weight limit, and what bullet will get you to 2500 yards with some consistency? It almost feels like a first year Differential Calculus optimization problem.
 
I always find these cartridge debates funny. Superior ballistics can only take the shooter/sniper so far. If the shooter/sniper can’t connect cold bore or at least w a 2nd round hit, your superior cartridge is pointless!
 
  • Like
Reactions: stefan73
If tiny angular movements in the rifles initial firing position can have large effects at 2500m, then cartridges producing larger recoil pulses will be more susceptible to accuracy issues. These will be field rifles. No one is going to be lugging around the lates and greatest f-class/bench rest/ELR bipods, rests, bags, rear bag elevators, etc.

Also, one cannot rely on the mass of the weapon system to reduce movement since there is a restriction.

Additionally, military snipers are not as great of shooters as Hollywood would have you think. Most of y'all know this but never speak about it.
 
If tiny angular movements in the rifles initial firing position can have large effects at 2500m, then cartridges producing larger recoil pulses will be more susceptible to accuracy issues. These will be field rifles. No one is going to be lugging around the lates and greatest f-class/bench rest/ELR bipods, rests, bags, rear bag elevators, etc.

Also, one cannot rely on the mass of the weapon system to reduce movement since there is a restriction.

Additionally, military snipers are not as great of shooters as Hollywood would have you think. Most of y'all know this but never speak about it.
Screen_Shot_2020-10-05_at_11.51.58_AM.png
 
I was hoping the :ROFLMAO: would be enough to convey the joke. Nothing personal taken - I actually agree with you. But 1994 recent SOTIC Level 2 grad me would be like "Halts Maul, junge!", but 2004 me in Mosul would be like "of course you dickheads couldn't hit the dude taking his time getting on that moped"
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: lash and stefan73
Does anyone have intel on what rifles were submitted? Someone mentioned Barrett is out! I can’t see AI building a rifle and making weight. That leaves DT or Cadex. Did I miss any big names?
 
  • Like
Reactions: stefan73
I was hoping the :ROFLMAO: would be enough to convey the joke. Nothing personal taken - I actually agree with you. But 1994 recent SOTIC Level 2 grad me would be like "Halts Maul, junge!", but 2004 me in Mosul would be like "of course you dickheads couldn't hit the dude taking his time getting on that moped"
you left out "diene", I usually just say "halts deine maul du sau" (I might add another explicative or two in there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lash
Does anyone have intel on what rifles were submitted? Someone mentioned Barrett is out! I can’t see AI building a rifle and making weight. That leaves DT or Cadex. Did I miss any big names?
That would actually be interesting to know. I don't think Sako has anything that would work in those specs but I could be wrong. Victrix has some systems.
 
.338LM Improved is a much better .338LM, but with .33XC you can get virgin brass. Shooting .50BMG all day in the Army felt like I was giving myself a concussion; shooting .338LM all day sometimes hurts my shoulder; but I can shoot .300NM all weekend AND it has a much better selection of bullets.
33xc will never be excepted it just like enabelr requires a cheytac length box at that tim why not just use the cheytac
 
  • Like
Reactions: stefan73
If tiny angular movements in the rifles initial firing position can have large effects at 2500m, then cartridges producing larger recoil pulses will be more susceptible to accuracy issues. These will be field rifles. No one is going to be lugging around the lates and greatest f-class/bench rest/ELR bipods, rests, bags, rear bag elevators, etc.

Also, one cannot rely on the mass of the weapon system to reduce movement since there is a restriction.

Additionally, military snipers are not as great of shooters as Hollywood would have you think. Most of y'all know this but never speak about it.
Great points honestly. At 2500m who is making first round steel on target hits?

Reminds me of the TIC A Co had in Afghanistan in the Arghandab just above Mizan. The snipers couldn't get the Afghans that were using plunging fire from mountain tops with PKM's at around 2200m's so the 11C's stepped in with the 60mm mortars and solved the problems. They were in a TIC for about a week and I had taken all of the air in RC south for that operation. Fun days, not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lash and JB.IC
Great points honestly. At 2500m who is making first round steel on target hits?

Reminds me of the TIC A Co had in Afghanistan in the Arghandab just above Mizan. The snipers couldn't get the Afghans that were using plunging fire from mountain tops with PKM's at around 2200m's so the 11C's stepped in with the 60mm mortars and solved the problems. They were in a TIC for about a week and I had taken all of the air in RC south for that operation. Fun days, not.

2010!?
 
33xc all day over 338lm
So I'm at the point of having to call the ball on chamber on a gun I'm building and I'm frankly pretty hard pressed to just say 33xc. I don't care about the barrel life since I regard that as a wear item. The pervasive view that the 33xc is a finicky son of a bitch with loads is what I get hung on. Seeing people shoot lights out one match and string vertically the next gives good weight to that perspective.

The truth is, the LM is about 90% as good as an XC and a LMAI is probably just about on par for where most people end up velocity wise with the XC. You certainly have an edge in the supersonic range but it is only 100 to 150 yards with real world loads rather than max speeds.

The funny thing is that the 33xc is the only reason I would consider a LMAI. Since I can just full length size 33xc brass down to LMAI and trim the neck, it is much more attractive than if I had to fire form and all that crap.

-Alex
 
So I'm at the point of having to call the ball on chamber on a gun I'm building and I'm frankly pretty hard pressed to just say 33xc. I don't care about the barrel life since I regard that as a wear item. The pervasive view that the 33xc is a finicky son of a bitch with loads is what I get hung on. Seeing people shoot lights out one match and string vertically the next gives good weight to that perspective.

The truth is, the LM is about 90% as good as an XC and a LMAI is probably just about on par for where most people end up velocity wise with the XC. You certainly have an edge in the supersonic range but it is only 100 to 150 yards with real world loads rather than max speeds.

The funny thing is that the 33xc is the only reason I would consider a LMAI. Since I can just full length size 33xc brass down to LMAI and trim the neck, it is much more attractive than if I had to fire form and all that crap.

-Alex
All this and the fact that you can't magazine feed with the XC from the Lapua Magnum sized magazines puts you into a Cheytac sized action anyways. I've been thinking the LMAI with a 30" barrel would make it hard to justify the 33XC.
 
All this and the fact that you can't magazine feed with the XC from the Lapua Magnum sized magazines puts you into a Cheytac sized action anyways. I've been thinking the LMAI with a 30" barrel would make it hard to justify the 33XC.
I had a few 338 LM AI before switching to 33xc. 33xc is the easy button but comes at the cost of barrel life.

338 LM AI w modified mags if you want to mag feed…
33XC if you don’t mind running a SS!
 
So I'm at the point of having to call the ball on chamber on a gun I'm building and I'm frankly pretty hard pressed to just say 33xc. I don't care about the barrel life since I regard that as a wear item. The pervasive view that the 33xc is a finicky son of a bitch with loads is what I get hung on. Seeing people shoot lights out one match and string vertically the next gives good weight to that perspective.

The truth is, the LM is about 90% as good as an XC and a LMAI is probably just about on par for where most people end up velocity wise with the XC. You certainly have an edge in the supersonic range but it is only 100 to 150 yards with real world loads rather than max speeds.

The funny thing is that the 33xc is the only reason I would consider a LMAI. Since I can just full length size 33xc brass down to LMAI and trim the neck, it is much more attractive than if I had to fire form and all that crap.

-Alex
I have not had to tweak my 33xc load w solids in 450 rounds. I’m running a Bart modBB 1-7.5 twist..Even after the throat moved a mile. Velocity dropped but my load is still in tune. I have not experienced any vertical stringing from my verified load I run. Now, I may not be so lucky w my next barrel as this one is about to be retired.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lash
I have not had to tweak my 33xc load w solids in 450 rounds. I’m running a Bart modBB 1-7.5 twist..Even after the throat moved a mile. Velocity dropped but my load is still in tune. I have not experienced any vertical stringing from my verified load I run. Now, I may not be so lucky w my next barrel as this one is about to be retired.
450 seems bad even for a 33xc. What is your MV like?

-Alex
 
450 seems bad even for a 33xc. What is your MV like?

-Alex
Well after I seasoned the throat 😉, 3140 fps has been my best 3 out 4 at ELR distance w almost perfect conditions.

I had some solids going over 3300 fps in early load development w n570. My buddy’s barrel went around 500 rounds w H50 BMG and Berger 300 OTM.

We pay 💰 to play 🤣
 
Well after I seasoned the throat 😉, 3140 fps has been my best 3 out 4 at ELR distance w almost perfect conditions.

I had some solids going over 3300 fps in early load development w n570. My buddy’s barrel went around 500 rounds w H50 BMG and Berger 300 OTM.

We pay 💰 to play 🤣
I'm surprised that you found a good node up there. Seems like most people end up a bit over 3000. I guess twist rate is going to affect harmonics. How tall was the node you are loading for?

-Alex
 
Alex, I’m going to PM you. I don’t want to side track this thread. I’m excited to hear more about the 375 enabler from shooters that have experience with it. It’s been on my radar for a few years.
 
waiting for you to toss in the 260 rem as well, and hit the trifecta.
BABYGUPPY: While you are at it why not include all the classic cartridges the the great majority of the shooting community shoots. So that only what you think is cool is left in your small world. Why don't you take your opinion back to the bear pit where you belong.
 
BABYGUPPY: While you are at it why not include all the classic cartridges the the great majority of the shooting community shoots. So that only what you think is cool is left in your small world. Why don't you take your opinion back to the bear pit where you belong.
ahh, troll.
'You' was sarcastic comment to @Huskydriver ; since he was having some fun. I did laugh; since I shoot and own most of the calibers that Husky makes fun of ;)
this 'you' is to you aka @cuirc - just 'you' don't misunderstand to whom I'm referring to.
You need to ease up on the Prozac and can take a long walk off a short pier. You can take your opinion and place it in your six, along where most of talking that you do comes from. AKA - GFY and have a nice day :)
 
BABYGUPPY: since I referred to the wrong person, I stand corrected and apologize. Have a nice day
@Huskydriver: While you are at it why not include all the classic cartridges the great majority of the shooting community shoots. So that only what you think is cool is left in your small world. Why don't you take your opinion back to the bear pit. I shoot probably most of the calibers you find in distain also. Have a nice day.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: stefan73 and lash