On an impulse, I picked up a 2.5-10x Mk 4HD. I've gotta say, I like it. Image quality, depth of field and field of view are all fine. I really like that it's light and relatively short. I like compact scopes.
The whole issue with the zero stop not lining up is something that I noticed right off. I read of some fixes a couple of pages back and took a good look at it and made some observations.
First, i noticed that the hash mark on the body is much wider than the marks on the dial and further noticed that there is slop in the turrets. I don't know if this was by design or a fortunate accident, but the hash mark on the body is about as wide as the amount of slop in the turrets. What I did was zero the scope. I then dialed up 1 mil and reset the turret lining the 1 mil mark up with the mark on the body, such that twisting in the slop, leaves the mark on the dial lined up within the mark on the body. There is no mistaking where the dial is. Now, no matter where you dial, the mark on the knob is within the mark on the body.
If you reset the dial with the dial at zero, it will leave the marks misaligned throughout rotation.
On my particular scope, once the knob was set to track correctly, the zero stop wouldn't fully engage at zero. This is where I tried what was mentioned earlier by another poster. I removed the knob and used a file to slowly remove material from the zero stop collar until the zero stop locked into place. Don't remove too much. In my case, removing too much would have resulted in possibly being able to dial -.1 mil with the zero stop engaged.
Now, my OCD is satisfied and everything lines up. I took it out to 500 yesterday and the scope seems to track correctly and I never had to question where the dial was.
I agree that we shouldn't have to deal with these issues, but it seems that unless you're willing to spend north of 2500 on a scope, you're gonna be dealing with something. Shoot, Nightforce NX8 LPVO (I have tape around the diopter because the locking ring won't stay put), Vortex Razor (I keep managing to bend the ocular bell), Primary Arms PLXc (gotta adjust diopter to get a decent image on 8x, if you set it up on 1X), Vortex PST 2-10x (turrets seems to have a mind of there own and won't stay put).
In the end, im happy with the Mk4. Kinda wish the illumination was better. The anti cant feature is useless if you can't see the illumination. Or maybe I'm doing something wrong.