Re: Battle Stocks for ARs
All person to person bashing aside, I'll try to look at this from a "cost benefit" perspective. The thread presumes that the rifle has gone down, so the rifle has to be used as a club for a "last ditch" weapon. The collapsable stocks weak point is where the aluminum tube joins up with the aluminum lower receiver. I suppose it would be possible to have a machinist make a steel buffer tube, and have someone custom design/make a stock to fit onto the steel buffer tube. However, you would still be stuck with the aluminum lower receiver joint. This is a very weak place for the kinds of forces I presume the OP is talking about.
So, even if you were able to get the world's sturdiest steel/carbon fiber (or whatever) butt stock system, you will still have the weak point where the stock joins the rifle. Sure, I suppose you could have the same machinist make a steel lower receiver...but that is an entirely different discussion.
All that being said, it appears that whatever kind of stock you get will only give you one good butt stroke before the joining point of the butt stock and lower receiver fails.
As long as it will most likely fail anyhow, have something cheap for the pre-failure butt stroke, and spend the money that would have been spent designing and manufacturing the super strong collapsable butt stock on something like a reliable pistol, tomahawk, short sword, knife, battle ax or whatever you desire as a back up weapon.
After all, the whole point is what to transition to after your rifle runs out of ammo or otherwise fails. And there is a plethora of information about transition drills, recommendations for secondary equipment and so on. A super strong custom butt stock places well below any of the other secondary weapons I mentioned in the previous paragraph.
If most of the experts have already evaluated the possible scenarios and made their recommendations about what to transition to and how to make the transition, taking that advice would be prudent. Rejecting consistent recommendations from a variety of experts is at the best, unwise; at the worst, downright stupid.
I'm not claiming to be an expert, just someone with one of the points of view that the original posting requested.