Re: Best Scope For An African Safari
Thunderbolt:
I gladly run optics, especially as my eyes get older. But not under all circumstances and my Africa trip was one of those times.
I am comfortable hitting vitals w. iron sights out to 100 yds. 150 with a rest. My buffalo was standing still and I had time to wait for an opening. My moose was 124 yards and I had 10 minutes to get into a sitting position, rest rifle over a log and wait for the perfect broadside shot.
In either case, would a scope have been useful? Possibly, but I chose against and was glad I did. For Africa, I felt it was something else to get stolen or go wrong... perhaps not likely with a S&B or Leica... but I didn't have one of those. Were I going again... my eyesight at 45 isn't what it was at 35, especially close up. Rear sights are harder to acquire.... Sure, today I might pick a scope.
And the reason I didn't take a scoped rifle for moose was we were in terrible raining/snowing conditions and my partner (with whom I shared the tag) had the scoped rifle. We had agreed that he would take any longer shots and I would be able to handle backups or snap shots or shoot if his scope had issues (we were using one of the experimental -- at the time -- Adirondak Optics video scopes loaned to us by Terry Gordon... so we didn't fully trust it. As it turned out, I got a 'long' shot while he was scoping a hollow about 50 yds away from me on the other side of a small ridge. His scope worked great, but he never got to shoot at a moose.
And I still carry open sight rifle more than half the time during deer and all the time during muzzleloader season. Does it limit my shooting options to shorter shots? Yes, but on Vermont ridges, swamps, etc. my shots are almost all <50 yds anyway.
Had I been faced w. a charging animal as you were, I doubt I'd have even used sights... more likely I would have made a snap shot. At 12 feet, I don't think I would have had the presence of mind to use a scope as effectively as you did. But having never been in that position 'for real' it's an academic question. Personally, I think I would have had more trouble acquiring through the scope but that's just me.
Probably the best advice for Superwolf is to use (or not use) a scope as a matter of personal preference. There are good arguments for both options. Whatever you do, practice, practice. Not all shots will be simple, calm and un-dramatic as mine. If you can't use your gear under extreme stress as Thunderbolt was forced to do... remember M'bogo kills 200 people a year in Africa.
Cheers,
Pierce